Skip to content
Flood Cost by ZIP

States / Florida / St. Johns County / St. Augustine Shores / 32086

Flood costs in 32086, St. Augustine Shores

Updated 2026-11-20. FEMA claims as of 2026-11-16.

ZIP 32086 in St. Augustine Shores, St. Johns County has 135 NFIP flood claims in the OpenFEMA claims snapshot. The median building-plus-contents payment is $7,438, and those payments add up to $1,475,374.

By claim count it ranks 455th of 1,353 Florida ZIPs with at least one claim, and 5th of 13 in St. Johns County.

NFIP claims dated 2021 through 2025 in this ZIP (9) are fewer than claims dated 2016 through 2020 (61). That is a count of dated claims, not a forecast.

The flood-event name FEMA used most often here is Hurricane Matthew: 33 claims and $697,338 paid on building and contents. FEMA left the event name blank on 51 claims.

The in-force policy filter has 1,019 records in this ZIP (1,432 insured units on those records) and a median premium of $394. That median is below the Florida median of $859 in the same filter.

14.1% of 1,019 records that have both a charged premium and a full-risk premium show a charged premium below the full-risk figure. The median full-risk premium on records that report one is $396.

1 claims are dated 2026. That year is not finished in this file.

Claims

135

Rank 455 of 1,353

Median paid

$7,438

Total $1,475,374

Policy records

1,019

1,432 insured units

Median premium

$394

14.1% below full-risk

Claims by year

21 claims are dated before 2000 and are left off the chart.

Claim counts by year
YearClaimsBuilding + contents paid
19811$419
19831$0
19851$0
19891$2,097
19923$0
19942$0
19954$5,219
19963$4,903
19981$7,186
19994$1,041
20018$22,946
20035$30,171
20047$9,553
20062$5,540
20074$69,964
20084$8,973
20095$80,987
20112$0
20132$28,267
20141$0
20153$117,810
201637$702,772
201721$244,472
20192$12,256
20201$0
20211$0
20226$97,036
20232$23,761
20261$0

Named flood events

FEMA flood eventClaimsPaid
Hurricane Matthew33$697,338
Hurricane Irma19$244,472
Torrential rain7$22,946
Hurricane Ian5$97,036
Tropical Storm Fay4$8,973
Hurricane Frances3$1,544
Hurricane Floyd3$1,041
Hurricane Jeanne2$5,527

Flood zone on the claim, not on a house

floodZoneCurrent is the zone FEMA stored for the insured building at the time of the file. It is not a determination that a specific address is in that zone today. Look up a building at the FEMA Flood Map Service Center. Zone letters are explained on the flood zone page.

Nearby ZIPs

Distance is between Census 2020 ZCTA internal points. The county is the Census ZCTA overlap.

Storm supplies people shop

Supplies shopped for a storm, shown beside the 32086 statistics. Nothing here is required by the claim history above.

  • Quick Dam

    Quick Dam 17-ft water-activated flood barrier

    A 17-foot water-activated barrier sold for doorways and garages. The Amazon listing says not to use it with salt water, which matters on a Florida coast.

    ASIN B0085S2DEU. The listing warns that salt water deflates the barrier.

    Check price on Amazon
  • Wayne

    Wayne CDU790 1/3 HP sump pump

    A submersible pump for an indoor sump basin. The listing says indoor use. It does not stop storm surge from entering a house.

    ASIN B0002YVQA2.

    Check price on Amazon
  • Govee

    Govee water leak detector

    A battery water alarm with a local siren for a kitchen, bath, or utility room. The listing says this pack does not connect to Wi-Fi by itself.

    ASIN B0B77P3NQC.

    Check price on Amazon
  • Champion Power Equipment

    Champion 4500-watt dual-fuel inverter generator

    The listing describes 3,500 running watts on gasoline and 3,150 running watts on propane, both under Florida's 10,000 running-watt line for portable engine-driven generators. Run any generator outdoors, away from doors and windows.

    ASIN B0CPT83MTV. The listing cites a CO Shield shutoff. A shutoff is not a reason to run a generator indoors or in a garage.

    Check price on Amazon
  • Amazon search

    Hurricane window panels and shutters

    A search for panels and shutters, not one model. Opening protection is one of the improvements named in the My Safe Florida Home statute when an inspection recommends it.

    Search Amazon

Questions about this ZIP

How many NFIP flood claims does ZIP 32086 have?

The Florida slice of OpenFEMA NFIP Redacted Claims v3 has 135 claim records reported in ZIP 32086. 79 include a building or contents payment. The median of those payment totals is $7,438. Payments are historical. They are not a prediction for a house.

What flood events does FEMA name in ZIP 32086?

The most frequent flood-event label is Hurricane Matthew with 33 claims. 51 claims have no event name. A label is FEMA's catastrophe name, not a finding that every claim was caused only by that storm.

What is the median NFIP premium in ZIP 32086?

The median total insurance premium on 1,019 in-force policy records is $394. The median full-risk premium, where that field is positive, is $396. This is not a quote, not a comparison of insurers, and not a recommendation to buy a policy or a coverage amount.

OpenFEMA NFIP Redacted Claims v3 (FL as of 2026-11-16). OpenFEMA NFIP Redacted Policies v3, in-force on 2026-11-11. Retrieved 2026-11-20. This is not an official FEMA report. Claims dataset · Policies dataset · Methodology